{ "phase_id": "phase-02", "category_id": "architecture_engineering_core", "doc_id": "panel_navigation_spec", "source_path": "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/panel/data/panel_navigation_spec.json", "documentation_branch_status": "CUSTOM_BRANCH", "bucket_statuses_from_docs_index": { "Prerequisites": "ACTIVE", "Installation": "ACTIVE", "Configuration": "ACTIVE", "Validation": "ACTIVE", "Observable Evidence": "ACTIVE", "Failure Modes & Recovery": "ACTIVE", "Completion & Promotion": "ACTIVE" }, "exported_at": "2026-04-28T05:56:48.644291+00:00", "export_rule": "docs/json export generated from real panel/data source plus docs/index.php branch evidence; no authored content invented by export patch", "source_payload": { "canon_meta": { "canon_id": "devon-panel-navigation-spec", "version": "1.0.0", "status": "ACTIVE", "ui_mode": "claude_like_workspace_devon_governed" }, "layout": { "topbar": { "required_items": [ "project_selector", "server_selector", "deployment_stage_selector", "global_status_counters", "search_box", "quick_actions" ] }, "left_sidebar": { "role": "deployment_navigation", "groups": [ "host_readiness", "canon_control_plane", "server_registry", "foundation_infrastructure", "storage_state", "memory_control_plane", "core_runtime", "observability_audit_base", "remote_access_orchestration", "sandbox_orchestration", "cognition_base", "engineering_modules", "governance_policy", "benchmark_learning", "operator_panel", "promotion_rollback" ] }, "center_workspace": { "tabs": [ "preview", "artifact", "contract", "diff", "logs", "metrics", "timeline" ] }, "right_drawer_stack": { "drawers": [ "evidence_drawer", "dependency_drawer", "memory_scope_drawer", "validation_drawer", "server_scope_drawer" ] } }, "interaction_rules": { "default_open_behavior": { "left_sidebar": "open", "center_workspace": "preview", "right_drawer_stack": "evidence_drawer" }, "click_card_behavior": [ "open_contract_summary", "show_current_status", "show_evidence_list", "show_dependencies", "show_last_validation" ], "click_subcategory_behavior": [ "focus_matrix_row", "show_pipeline_steps", "show_expected_evidence", "show_status_rule" ], "status_colors": { "PASS": "canonical_green", "FAIL": "canonical_red", "MISSING": "canonical_amber" }, "counters_required": [ "total_cards", "pass_count", "fail_count", "missing_count", "by_stage_counts" ] }, "button_map": { "primary_buttons": [ "Open Contract", "Open Evidence", "View Pipeline", "View Dependencies", "View Timeline" ], "secondary_buttons": [ "Filter by Project", "Filter by Server", "Filter by Status", "Filter by Stage", "Filter by Memory Scope" ] }, "panel_data_sources": { "primary_matrix": "08_canonical_matrix_v1.yaml", "panel_tree": "02_panel_canonical_tree.yaml", "contract_schema": "03_card_contract_minimums.yaml", "deployment_order": "01_deployment_order_canonical.yaml" }, "initial_render_policy": { "matrix_driven": true, "evidence_only_status": true, "no_mock_status_allowed": true } }, "transition_status": "ACTIVE_DH_MIRROR", "hardening_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "hardening_priority": "schema_key_binding", "structural_contract": { "hardening_status": "HARDENING_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "transition_status": "ACTIVE_DH_MIRROR", "doc_id": "panel_navigation_spec", "category_id": "architecture_engineering_core", "phase_id": "phase-02", "hardening_lane": "json_schema_key_binding", "patch_type": "bind_schema_key_paths", "created_at": "2026-04-28T15:40:28.174408+00:00", "authority": { "authority_owner": "panel_navigation_spec.json", "canonical_role": "panel navigation authority", "authority_scope": "defines navigation behavior, category selection, hierarchy traversal and operator movement through canonical docs without changing canonical ownership", "panel_navigation_domain": [ "navigation hierarchy", "selection behavior", "breadcrumb consistency", "category routing" ], "not_authority_for": [ "canonical ownership", "component schema", "runtime status" ] }, "required_before": [ "panel navigation", "operator category routing", "future panel navigation runtime" ], "hard_dependencies": [ "panel_canonical_tree.json", "hub_index.json" ], "feeds_operational_ui": [ "left_navigation", "category_selector", "breadcrumb", "future_panel_navigation_reader" ], "bucket_contracts": { "Prerequisites": { "contract_role": "prove panel_navigation_spec.json is materially present, phase-bound and dependency-bound before downstream consumers use it", "required_structural_fields": [ "authority_owner", "canonical_role", "required_before", "hard_dependencies", "panel_navigation_domain" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" }, "Installation": { "contract_role": "make panel_navigation_spec available as a Documentation Hub mirror with fixed technical identity and branch binding", "required_structural_fields": [ "doc_id", "category_id", "phase_id", "documentation_branch_status", "source_path", "expected_bindings" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" }, "Configuration": { "contract_role": "bind panel_navigation_spec authority scope, dependency boundaries and forbidden ownership classes into parseable structure", "required_structural_fields": [ "authority_scope", "not_authority_for", "panel_navigation_domain", "boundary_rules" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" }, "Validation": { "contract_role": "convert panel_navigation_spec into deterministic PASS, FAIL and MISSING checks for identity, binding, source and authority boundary", "required_structural_fields": [ "validation_checks", "pass_criteria", "fail_criteria", "missing_criteria" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" }, "Observable Evidence": { "contract_role": "expose file paths, DH branch binding, source payload shape and mirror path proving panel_navigation_spec is observable", "required_structural_fields": [ "evidence_paths", "expected_bindings", "observable_checks" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" }, "Failure Modes & Recovery": { "contract_role": "recover missing source, wrong binding, dependency break, authority overreach and false promotion for panel_navigation_spec", "required_structural_fields": [ "failure_modes", "recovery_actions", "rollback_or_safe_state" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" }, "Completion & Promotion": { "contract_role": "promote panel_navigation_spec only as hardened DH mirror input, not as final engine-grade contract", "required_structural_fields": [ "done_when", "not_done_when", "promotion_gate", "canonization_gate" ], "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium" } }, "validation_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_doc_identity", "type": "exact_value", "path": "$.doc_id", "expected": "panel_navigation_spec", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_category_binding", "type": "exact_value", "path": "$.category_id", "expected": "architecture_engineering_core", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_phase_binding", "type": "exact_value", "path": "$.phase_id", "expected": "phase-02", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_branch_status", "type": "exact_value", "path": "$.documentation_branch_status", "expected": "CUSTOM_BRANCH", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_authority_owner_declared", "type": "exact_value", "path": "$.structural_contract.authority.authority_owner", "expected": "panel_navigation_spec.json", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_not_engine_final", "type": "exact_value", "path": "$.engine_grade_final", "expected": false, "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_source_payload_object_present", "type": "object_present", "path": "$.source_payload", "on_missing": "MISSING", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_depends_on_panel_canonical_tree_json", "type": "array_contains", "path": "$.structural_contract.hard_dependencies", "expected": "panel_canonical_tree.json", "on_fail": "FAIL" }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_depends_on_hub_index_json", "type": "array_contains", "path": "$.structural_contract.hard_dependencies", "expected": "hub_index.json", "on_fail": "FAIL" } ], "evidence_paths": [ "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/panel/data/panel_navigation_spec.json", "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/docs/index.php", "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/panel/data/hub_index.json", "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/panel/data/master_architecture_index.md", "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/docs/json/phase-02/panel_navigation_spec.json", "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/docs/json/phase-02/_phase02_hardening_queue.json" ], "expected_bindings": [ { "binding": "docs_index_custom_branch", "expected": "if (doc.id === \"panel_navigation_spec\" && state.categoryId === \"architecture_engineering_core\")" }, { "binding": "hub_index_phase", "expected_phase_id": "phase-02" }, { "binding": "hub_index_category", "expected_category_id": "architecture_engineering_core" } ], "failure_modes": [ { "failure_id": "panel_navigation_spec_source_missing", "status": "MISSING", "meaning": "panel_navigation_spec source cannot be read from declared source path", "recovery_action": "restore /home/yeff/public_html/devon/panel/data/panel_navigation_spec.json or the declared mirror source before hardening can continue" }, { "failure_id": "panel_navigation_spec_unbound_from_phase02", "status": "FAIL", "meaning": "panel_navigation_spec is present but not bound to phase-02 / architecture_engineering_core", "recovery_action": "restore hub_index and docs/index binding to the canonical Phase 02 category" }, { "failure_id": "panel_navigation_spec_dependency_missing", "status": "MISSING", "meaning": "panel_navigation_spec cannot prove declared hard dependencies", "recovery_action": "restore declared dependencies or block promotion until dependency validation passes" }, { "failure_id": "panel_navigation_spec_authority_overreach", "status": "FAIL", "meaning": "panel_navigation_spec claims authority outside its declared scope", "recovery_action": "revoke overreaching authority and route the claim to the owning document or contract" }, { "failure_id": "panel_navigation_spec_false_engine_promotion", "status": "FAIL", "meaning": "panel_navigation_spec is promoted as engine-grade final while still in DH mirror transition", "recovery_action": "restore ACTIVE_DH_MIRROR / HARDENING_PARTIAL and require deterministic schema validation before final promotion" } ], "promotion_gates": { "done_when": [ "panel_navigation_spec source exists materially", "panel_navigation_spec is registered under Phase 02", "panel_navigation_spec has a custom Documentation Hub branch", "panel_navigation_spec JSON mirror contains structural_contract", "panel_navigation_spec exposes authority, dependencies, evidence paths, validation checks and promotion gates as parseable fields" ], "not_done_when": [ "source payload is missing", "category binding is wrong", "declared dependency is absent", "authority scope is overreached", "engine_grade_final is set true before deterministic schema validation exists" ], "promotion_gate": "panel_navigation_spec may move to HARDENING_PARTIAL after structural_contract exists and verifies, but must not become engine_grade_final until all decisive checks are schema-backed and deterministic.", "canonization_gate": "panel_navigation_spec remains an ACTIVE_DH_MIRROR until authority, dependency, evidence, failure and promotion checks can be consumed without semantic prose interpretation." }, "parser_readiness_after_patch": "medium", "blocked_until_engine_grade_final": [ "all validation checks resolve from JSON key paths", "all required dependencies are machine-checkable", "all authority boundaries produce deterministic FAIL when violated", "future operational panel can consume the contract without reading source prose" ], "mirror_type": "json_mirror", "schema_binding": { "required_keys": [ "source_payload" ], "source_payload_key_paths": [ "$.source_payload", "$.structural_contract", "$.bucket_statuses_from_docs_index" ], "expected_values": { "$.phase_id": "phase-02", "$.category_id": "architecture_engineering_core", "$.doc_id": "panel_navigation_spec", "$.engine_grade_final": false, "$.transition_status": "ACTIVE_DH_MIRROR" }, "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING", "ACTIVE_DH_MIRROR", "HARDENING_PARTIAL" ], "deterministic_fail_modes": [ "wrong_doc_id", "wrong_category_id", "wrong_phase_id", "missing_source_payload", "authority_overreach", "false_engine_promotion" ], "missing_criteria": [ "source payload absent", "declared source file absent", "hard dependency absent where required" ], "schema_backed_validation": true }, "boundary_rules": [ { "rule_id": "navigation_cannot_rewrite_tree", "meaning": "navigation may traverse but not redefine canonical tree", "fail_state": "FAIL when navigation changes ownership order" }, { "rule_id": "selection_requires_technical_ids", "meaning": "navigation must use doc/category ids, not visible labels", "fail_state": "FAIL when label acts as id" } ], "required_keys": [ "source_payload" ], "schema_boundary_rules": [ { "rule_id": "navigation_cannot_rewrite_tree", "meaning": "navigation may traverse but not redefine canonical tree", "fail_state": "FAIL when navigation changes ownership order" }, { "rule_id": "selection_requires_technical_ids", "meaning": "navigation must use doc/category ids, not visible labels", "fail_state": "FAIL when label acts as id" } ], "source_signal_audit": { "source_payload_is_object": true, "source_payload_top_keys": [ "button_map", "canon_meta", "initial_render_policy", "interaction_rules", "layout", "panel_data_sources" ], "audit_note": "source_signal_audit records JSON mirror shape only; structural_contract remains governed by schema key binding and Phase 02 queue" }, "bucket_schema_checks": { "prerequisites": { "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "doc_identity", "phase_binding", "category_binding", "authority_owner_present", "hard_dependencies_present", "required_before_present" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.doc_id", "$.phase_id", "$.category_id", "$.structural_contract.authority.authority_owner", "$.structural_contract.hard_dependencies", "$.structural_contract.required_before" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_prerequisites_doc_identity", "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "doc_identity", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.doc_id", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_prerequisites_phase_binding", "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "phase_binding", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.phase_id", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_prerequisites_category_binding", "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "category_binding", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.category_id", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_prerequisites_authority_owner_present", "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "authority_owner_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.authority.authority_owner", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_prerequisites_hard_dependencies_present", "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "check_order": 5, "check_name": "hard_dependencies_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.hard_dependencies", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_prerequisites_required_before_present", "bucket_name": "Prerequisites", "bucket_key": "prerequisites", "check_order": 6, "check_name": "required_before_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.required_before", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } }, "installation": { "bucket_name": "Installation", "bucket_key": "installation", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "custom_branch_binding", "source_path_present", "documentation_status", "dh_mirror_status" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.documentation_branch_status", "$.source_path", "$.transition_status", "$.hardening_status" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_installation_custom_branch_binding", "bucket_name": "Installation", "bucket_key": "installation", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "custom_branch_binding", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.documentation_branch_status", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_installation_source_path_present", "bucket_name": "Installation", "bucket_key": "installation", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "source_path_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.source_path", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_installation_documentation_status", "bucket_name": "Installation", "bucket_key": "installation", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "documentation_status", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.transition_status", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_installation_dh_mirror_status", "bucket_name": "Installation", "bucket_key": "installation", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "dh_mirror_status", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.hardening_status", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } }, "configuration": { "bucket_name": "Configuration", "bucket_key": "configuration", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "authority_scope_present", "domain_present", "forbidden_authority_boundary", "feeds_operational_ui_present" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.structural_contract.authority.authority_scope", "$.structural_contract.authority", "$.structural_contract.authority.not_authority_for", "$.structural_contract.feeds_operational_ui" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_configuration_authority_scope_present", "bucket_name": "Configuration", "bucket_key": "configuration", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "authority_scope_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.authority.authority_scope", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_configuration_domain_present", "bucket_name": "Configuration", "bucket_key": "configuration", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "domain_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.authority", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_configuration_forbidden_authority_boundary", "bucket_name": "Configuration", "bucket_key": "configuration", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "forbidden_authority_boundary", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.authority.not_authority_for", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_configuration_feeds_operational_ui_present", "bucket_name": "Configuration", "bucket_key": "configuration", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "feeds_operational_ui_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.feeds_operational_ui", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } }, "validation": { "bucket_name": "Validation", "bucket_key": "validation", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "validation_checks_present", "validation_checks_are_key_bound", "fail_missing_outcomes_declared", "engine_final_blocked" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.structural_contract.validation_checks", "$.structural_contract.schema_binding", "$.structural_contract.schema_binding.deterministic_fail_modes", "$.engine_grade_final" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_validation_validation_checks_present", "bucket_name": "Validation", "bucket_key": "validation", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "validation_checks_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.validation_checks", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_validation_validation_checks_are_key_bound", "bucket_name": "Validation", "bucket_key": "validation", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "validation_checks_are_key_bound", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.schema_binding", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_validation_fail_missing_outcomes_declared", "bucket_name": "Validation", "bucket_key": "validation", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "fail_missing_outcomes_declared", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.schema_binding.deterministic_fail_modes", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_validation_engine_final_blocked", "bucket_name": "Validation", "bucket_key": "validation", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "engine_final_blocked", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.engine_grade_final", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } }, "observable_evidence": { "bucket_name": "Observable Evidence", "bucket_key": "observable_evidence", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "evidence_paths_present", "doc_json_path_present", "expected_bindings_present", "source_signal_audit_present" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.structural_contract.evidence_paths", "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/docs/json/phase-02/panel_navigation_spec.json", "$.structural_contract.expected_bindings", "$.structural_contract.source_signal_audit" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_observable_evidence_evidence_paths_present", "bucket_name": "Observable Evidence", "bucket_key": "observable_evidence", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "evidence_paths_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.evidence_paths", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_observable_evidence_doc_json_path_present", "bucket_name": "Observable Evidence", "bucket_key": "observable_evidence", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "doc_json_path_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/docs/json/phase-02/panel_navigation_spec.json", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_observable_evidence_expected_bindings_present", "bucket_name": "Observable Evidence", "bucket_key": "observable_evidence", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "expected_bindings_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.expected_bindings", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_observable_evidence_source_signal_audit_present", "bucket_name": "Observable Evidence", "bucket_key": "observable_evidence", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "source_signal_audit_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.source_signal_audit", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } }, "failure_modes_recovery": { "bucket_name": "Failure Modes & Recovery", "bucket_key": "failure_modes_recovery", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "failure_modes_present", "recovery_actions_declared", "rollback_or_safe_state_present", "false_engine_promotion_blocked" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.structural_contract.failure_modes", "$.structural_contract.failure_modes[*].recovery_action", "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.not_done_when", "$.structural_contract.schema_binding.deterministic_fail_modes" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_failure_modes_recovery_failure_modes_present", "bucket_name": "Failure Modes & Recovery", "bucket_key": "failure_modes_recovery", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "failure_modes_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.failure_modes", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_failure_modes_recovery_recovery_actions_declared", "bucket_name": "Failure Modes & Recovery", "bucket_key": "failure_modes_recovery", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "recovery_actions_declared", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.failure_modes[*].recovery_action", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_failure_modes_recovery_rollback_or_safe_state_present", "bucket_name": "Failure Modes & Recovery", "bucket_key": "failure_modes_recovery", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "rollback_or_safe_state_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.not_done_when", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_failure_modes_recovery_false_engine_promotion_blocked", "bucket_name": "Failure Modes & Recovery", "bucket_key": "failure_modes_recovery", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "false_engine_promotion_blocked", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.schema_binding.deterministic_fail_modes", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } }, "completion_promotion": { "bucket_name": "Completion & Promotion", "bucket_key": "completion_promotion", "schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "engine_grade_final": false, "validation_mode": "schema_backed_transition", "parser_readiness": "medium", "next_patch_type": "expand_bucket_level_schema_checks", "required_schema_checks": [ "done_when_present", "not_done_when_present", "promotion_gate_present", "canonization_gate_present", "engine_final_requires_schema" ], "target_key_paths": [ "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.done_when", "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.not_done_when", "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.promotion_gate", "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.canonization_gate", "$.engine_grade_final" ], "schema_checks": [ { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_completion_promotion_done_when_present", "bucket_name": "Completion & Promotion", "bucket_key": "completion_promotion", "check_order": 1, "check_name": "done_when_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.done_when", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_completion_promotion_not_done_when_present", "bucket_name": "Completion & Promotion", "bucket_key": "completion_promotion", "check_order": 2, "check_name": "not_done_when_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.not_done_when", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_completion_promotion_promotion_gate_present", "bucket_name": "Completion & Promotion", "bucket_key": "completion_promotion", "check_order": 3, "check_name": "promotion_gate_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.promotion_gate", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_completion_promotion_canonization_gate_present", "bucket_name": "Completion & Promotion", "bucket_key": "completion_promotion", "check_order": 4, "check_name": "canonization_gate_present", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.structural_contract.promotion_gates.canonization_gate", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false }, { "check_id": "panel_navigation_spec_completion_promotion_engine_final_requires_schema", "bucket_name": "Completion & Promotion", "bucket_key": "completion_promotion", "check_order": 5, "check_name": "engine_final_requires_schema", "type": "key_path_declared", "target_key_path": "$.engine_grade_final", "expected_result": "observable_or_declared", "pass_when": "target key path exists or declared evidence path is present in the category JSON structural contract", "fail_when": "target key path is contradicted, malformed, or points outside the declared Phase 02 category contract", "missing_when": "target key path is absent and no declared evidence path can support the bucket requirement", "allowed_statuses": [ "PASS", "FAIL", "MISSING" ], "engine_grade_final_required": false } ], "deterministic_outcomes": { "PASS": "all required bucket key paths resolve or are explicitly declared as evidence-backed transitional paths", "FAIL": "one or more required bucket key paths contradict the declared category contract", "MISSING": "one or more required bucket key paths are absent and have no evidence-backed declaration" }, "blocked_until": [ "bucket has explicit key-bound checks", "bucket has deterministic PASS/FAIL/MISSING outcomes", "bucket can be consumed by future operational panel without prose interpretation" ], "promotion_rule": "bucket cannot promote to BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY until each check resolves from deterministic JSON key paths without prose interpretation", "future_panel_consumption": { "consumer": "future operational panel", "mode": "read bucket_schema_checks before treating bucket as executable contract input", "prohibited": "do not treat DH mirror prose as final engine-grade proof" } } }, "bucket_schema_expansion_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "bucket_schema_expanded_at": "2026-04-28T16:02:07.109195+00:00", "bucket_schema_expansion_rule": { "source_queue": "/home/yeff/public_html/devon/docs/json/phase-02/_phase02_bucket_schema_expansion_queue.json", "bucket_count": 7, "engine_grade_final": false, "allowed_next_status": [ "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "BUCKET_SCHEMA_READY" ], "not_final_reason": "checks are now bucket-scoped and schema-declared, but still require deterministic key-path resolver validation before engine_grade_final can become true" } }, "bucket_schema_status": "BUCKET_SCHEMA_PARTIAL", "updated_at": "2026-04-28T16:02:07.109220+00:00" }